Most people think if it’s sold in a store or online as a "natural" remedy, it’s safe. That’s not true. The FDA has issued dozens of warnings in the last five years about herbal products that can cause serious harm-especially when mixed with prescription drugs. And the worst part? Many users never tell their doctors they’re taking them.
Why Your Doctor Needs to Know What You’re Taking
You might think taking turmeric for joint pain or ashwagandha for stress is harmless. But here’s the reality: herbal supplements aren’t tested like prescription drugs. They don’t go through clinical trials. They don’t need FDA approval before hitting the shelves. The FDA only steps in after something goes wrong.That’s why disclosure matters. If you’re on blood thinners like warfarin and start taking ginkgo biloba, you could bleed internally without warning. If you’re on antidepressants and add St. John’s wort, you risk serotonin syndrome-a potentially fatal condition. These aren’t rare cases. A 2018 study in JAMA Internal Medicine found that nearly 800 supplements contained hidden pharmaceutical ingredients. Some had antidepressants, erectile dysfunction drugs, or steroids-none listed on the label.
Doctors don’t ask because they assume you’ll tell them. But according to a 2022 survey of physicians, 68% say patients never mention supplements during visits. That silence can be deadly.
Herbal Products the FDA Has Warned About
The FDA doesn’t issue warnings lightly. When they do, it’s because something dangerous is happening. Here are the most common herbal products linked to serious health risks:- Ginkgo biloba: Increases bleeding risk when taken with aspirin, NSAIDs, or warfarin. At least 12 FDA warning letters since 2018 cite ginkgo products with undisclosed blood-thinning agents.
- St. John’s wort: Interacts with over 50 medications, including antidepressants, birth control, HIV drugs, and chemotherapy. It can make your pills stop working.
- Green tea extract: Linked to over 100 cases of acute liver injury since 2015. The FDA issued a warning in 2022 after multiple hospitalizations from high-dose capsules marketed for weight loss.
- Kava: Banned in Canada and Europe for liver damage. The FDA has issued multiple alerts since 2002, yet it’s still sold in U.S. stores.
- Comfrey and coltsfoot: Contain pyrrolizidine alkaloids-poisons that cause irreversible liver damage. The FDA banned these in oral products in 2001, but they’re still found in teas and tinctures.
- Yohimbe: Marketed for sexual performance, but often contains undeclared stimulants. Over 200 adverse event reports since 2019, including heart attacks and strokes.
These aren’t outliers. They’re red flags. And the FDA keeps finding them in products labeled as "pure" or "organic."
How Supplements Slip Through the Cracks
The Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act (DSHEA) of 1994 lets companies sell supplements without proving they’re safe or effective. All they need to do is notify the FDA if they’re using a "new dietary ingredient." That’s it. No safety data. No efficacy proof. No pre-market review.Compare that to prescription drugs. A new drug takes 8-12 years and over $2 billion to get approved. Supplements? They can be on Amazon tomorrow. The FDA has only banned two ingredients since DSHEA passed: ephedra in 2004 and methylsynephrine in 2022.
The agency has 45 staff members to oversee 30,000 supplement companies. That’s less than one person per 670 businesses. Meanwhile, over 23,000 new supplement products enter the market every year.
Manufacturers exploit this gap. They slap on labels like "clinically proven" or "doctor-recommended"-even when no such studies exist. Some even add real drugs like sildenafil (Viagra) or sibutramine (a banned weight-loss drug) to boost effects. The FDA finds these in 15% of tested supplements, according to a JAMA Internal Medicine study.
What You Can Do to Stay Safe
You don’t have to give up supplements. But you need to be smarter about them. Here’s how:- Always tell your doctor. Say it out loud: "I’m taking ashwagandha, turmeric, and a multivitamin." Don’t assume they’ll ask. Bring the bottle to your appointment.
- Look for third-party verification. Check for the USP Verified Mark, NSF Certified for Sport, or ConsumerLab.com seal. These mean the product was tested for what’s on the label-and what’s not.
- Check the FDA’s warning list. Go to the FDA’s website and search their warning letters. Type in the product name. If it’s been flagged, walk away.
- Know the Latin names. Labels must list botanicals by scientific name. If you see "Hypericum perforatum" instead of just "St. John’s wort," that’s a good sign the maker follows labeling rules.
- Avoid products that promise miracles. If it claims to cure cancer, diabetes, or Alzheimer’s, it’s illegal-and dangerous. The FDA has issued over 1,800 warning letters since 2002 for these kinds of claims.
The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health offers a free app called "Supplement Your Knowledge" with over 1,200 evidence-based fact sheets. Use it. It’s the closest thing to a reliable guide you’ll find.
The Hidden Danger: Undeclared Ingredients
You might buy a "natural energy booster" labeled with green tea and ginseng. But lab tests show it also contains caffeine anhydrous, DMAA (a banned stimulant), and synephrine. These aren’t listed because they’re illegal to include.Weight loss, sexual enhancement, and bodybuilding supplements are the worst offenders. In one case, a product marketed as "herbal testosterone booster" was found to contain 10 times the legal dose of a steroid. Another, sold as a "natural libido enhancer," had sildenafil-the active ingredient in Viagra-hidden in the formula.
These aren’t mistakes. They’re deliberate. Manufacturers know people want fast results. They add drugs to make their products "work better." And they count on you not telling your doctor.
What Happens When You Don’t Disclose
A 2021 case report in the Journal of Clinical Pharmacy and Therapeutics tells the story of a 62-year-old man taking warfarin for a blood clot. He started taking ginkgo biloba for memory. He didn’t tell his doctor. Two weeks later, he was rushed to the ER with internal bleeding. His INR-a measure of blood clotting-was off the charts.He survived. But he spent six days in the hospital. He had to stop ginkgo. He had to restart his blood thinner at a lower dose. His doctor called it "entirely preventable."
That’s the pattern. People take supplements because they want to feel better. They don’t realize they’re putting themselves at risk. And when they don’t tell their doctor, the risk multiplies.
What’s Changing in 2025?
There’s momentum for reform. The Dietary Supplement Listing Act of 2023 (S.1088) would require companies to list every supplement with the FDA before selling it. That’s a big deal. Right now, companies don’t even have to tell the FDA what they’re selling.The FDA’s 2023-2027 Strategic Plan aims to cut adulterated products in high-risk categories by 25% within five years. They’re also pushing for better reporting tools and more lab testing.
Third-party verification is growing fast. In 2020, only 5% of supplements had USP verification. By 2025, experts predict that number will hit 15%. That’s progress. But it’s still a minority.
Until the system changes, the responsibility falls on you.
Bottom Line: Speak Up, Check Labels, Stay Informed
Herbal supplements aren’t inherently bad. But they’re not harmless either. The FDA’s warnings exist because real people are getting hurt. The system is broken. The rules are outdated. And the burden of safety is on the consumer.So here’s what you do: Tell your doctor. Check for verified seals. Avoid miracle claims. And if you feel weird after taking something-stop. Report it to the FDA’s Safety Reporting Portal. Even if you think it’s minor, your report could save someone else’s life.
You’re not being paranoid. You’re being smart.
Do herbal supplements need FDA approval before being sold?
No. Under the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act (DSHEA) of 1994, herbal supplements do not require FDA approval before being sold. Manufacturers only need to notify the FDA if they’re using a "new dietary ingredient," but they don’t have to prove safety or effectiveness. The FDA can only act after a product is on the market and found to be harmful or mislabeled.
Which herbal products are most likely to interact with medications?
St. John’s wort, ginkgo biloba, kava, and green tea extract are among the most problematic. St. John’s wort can reduce the effectiveness of birth control, antidepressants, and chemotherapy drugs. Ginkgo increases bleeding risk when taken with blood thinners like warfarin. Kava can cause liver damage, especially when combined with alcohol or acetaminophen. Green tea extract in high doses has been linked to acute liver injury.
How can I tell if a supplement is safe?
Look for third-party verification seals like USP Verified, NSF Certified for Sport, or ConsumerLab.com. These mean the product was independently tested for ingredients, purity, and potency. Avoid products that claim to cure diseases like cancer or diabetes. Check the FDA’s warning letter database for your product’s name. And always check the Latin name of botanicals on the label-this shows the manufacturer follows labeling rules.
Why don’t doctors always ask about supplements?
Many doctors assume patients will volunteer the information. But studies show 68% of patients don’t disclose supplement use during medical visits. Doctors are often pressed for time and may not think supplements are relevant. That’s why it’s critical for you to bring them up-especially if you’re on prescription medications.
Can I report a bad supplement to the FDA?
Yes. The FDA has a Safety Reporting Portal where consumers can submit reports of adverse events. You’ll need to provide details like the product name, dosage, symptoms, and when you started taking it. Even if you’re unsure, report it. The FDA uses these reports to identify dangerous products. Only about 12% of people complete the full report, but every one helps.
Comments
Lisa Detanna
November 24, 2025I used to take that ginkgo stuff for memory-until my grandma had a bleed and the ER doc asked if I was on anything weird. I said no. She said, 'Honey, you’re on ginkgo. Your INR’s through the roof.' I felt like an idiot. Now I bring every bottle to every appointment. No more guessing.
Doctors don’t ask because they assume you’ll tell them. But we don’t tell because we think it’s ‘just herbs.’ That’s the trap.
And yeah, the FDA’s understaffed. But if you’re gonna take something that could kill you, at least be honest with the person trying to keep you alive.
Demi-Louise Brown
November 25, 2025Supplements are not medicine. They are not regulated like medicine. They are not proven like medicine. And yet, people treat them as if they are.
Knowledge is power. Disclosure is responsibility.
Pramod Kumar
November 26, 2025Back home in India, we’ve been using turmeric and ashwagandha for centuries-but we never mixed them with warfarin or SSRIs without asking the vaidya. That’s the thing, folks. Tradition doesn’t mean ‘safe with everything.’ It means ‘safe when used with wisdom.’
Now we’ve got 20-somethings popping green tea extract capsules like candy because some influencer said it ‘burns fat.’ Meanwhile, their liver is screaming in silent, biochemical agony.
It’s not the herbs. It’s the hubris. We think ‘natural’ = ‘no consequences.’ That’s the lie that’s killing us.
Linda Rosie
November 27, 2025Bring the bottle. Say it out loud. That’s it.
Jennifer Shannon
November 28, 2025Okay, so let’s just sit with this for a second-because I think we’re all pretending this is just about ‘herbs’ when really, it’s about how we’ve outsourced our health to capitalism and convenience.
We live in a world where you can buy a ‘natural testosterone booster’ on Amazon Prime with two clicks, and it’s got more sildenafil than a pharmacy’s back stock-and you don’t even blink because the label says ‘organic’ and has a picture of a mountain.
And then we wonder why our doctors are confused when we show up with chest pain and a drawer full of unlabeled capsules.
The FDA isn’t the villain here. The villain is the idea that we can bypass science, bypass accountability, bypass conversation, and still be healthy.
And don’t even get me started on the ‘doctor-recommended’ nonsense-like, who? Which doctor? Did they get paid? Is their name on the bottle? No? Then it’s marketing. Not medicine.
Third-party seals? Yes. But even those aren’t perfect. I once found a USP-certified supplement that had a banned stimulant in it-because the test was done on a different batch. So now I check the lot number. And I Google the company. And I cry a little because this shouldn’t be this hard.
But here’s the thing: if you’re not willing to do the work, don’t take it. Because your liver doesn’t care how ‘clean’ your diet is. Your heart doesn’t care if you’re ‘spiritual.’ Your kidneys just want you to stop mixing St. John’s wort with your antidepressants.
And yes, I know it’s annoying to bring bottles to appointments. But I’d rather be annoying than dead. And I’d rather be annoying than the reason my doctor has to write a death certificate because ‘the patient didn’t mention the supplement.’
So yes. Bring the bottle. Say it out loud. And if you’re still skeptical? Read the FDA warning letters. Just one. Just one, and you’ll never look at a ‘natural energy booster’ the same way again.
Suzan Wanjiru
November 28, 2025USP seal is your best friend. Skip anything without it. And never trust anything that says 'clinically proven' without a link to the study. Most of those are just made up.
Also green tea extract is not a weight loss miracle. It's a liver bomb. Stop it.
Henrik Stacke
November 29, 2025There is a quiet, terrifying irony here: we live in an age of unprecedented medical knowledge, yet we choose to self-medicate with substances that bypass every safeguard we’ve built over centuries.
It’s not just negligence. It’s a cultural surrender to the myth of effortless wellness.
The FDA isn’t failing because it’s underfunded-it’s failing because we’ve stopped asking the right questions. We don’t ask, ‘Is this safe?’ We ask, ‘Does it work fast?’
And that’s the real tragedy.
Manjistha Roy
December 1, 2025Man, I’ve seen so many people in my community take kava because it’s ‘natural chill pill’-but no one tells their doctor they’re also on high blood pressure meds. Then they end up in the ER with jaundice and a confused cardiologist. It’s heartbreaking. And preventable.
And the labels? So misleading. ‘Pure botanical blend’-but the fine print? Zero. No ingredients listed. No warnings. Just pretty packaging and promises.
We need better labeling. We need education. We need to stop treating herbal supplements like they’re tea.
They’re not. They’re pharmaceuticals in disguise.
And if you’re taking them, you’re playing Russian roulette with your liver.
Jennifer Skolney
December 1, 2025Y’all, I used to take that ‘stress relief’ ashwagandha every night… until I started having weird heart palpitations. I told my doctor and she said, ‘Oh honey, that’s a known interaction with your beta-blocker.’ 😳 I had no idea. Now I bring every bottle to every visit. I even take pics of the labels. And I tell my mom to do the same. 🙏
It’s not weird. It’s smart. And it saves lives.
JD Mette
December 2, 2025I’ve been taking turmeric for years. Never had a problem. But I also never told my doctor. Maybe I should have. I’ll mention it next time. That’s all.
Olanrewaju Jeph
December 3, 2025The regulatory gap in the dietary supplement industry is not merely a policy failure-it is a systemic ethical collapse. The absence of pre-market safety evaluation, coupled with the proliferation of adulterated products, constitutes a public health emergency that is being normalized under the guise of consumer freedom.
It is not sufficient to rely on post-market surveillance when the harm is irreversible. The burden of proof must shift from the consumer to the manufacturer. Until then, the most prudent course of action is informed caution, third-party verification, and full disclosure to licensed medical practitioners.
Every unreported supplement is a potential sentinel event waiting to be documented in a medical journal.
Karla Morales
December 4, 2025OMG I JUST REALIZED I’VE BEEN TAKING ‘ENERGY BOOSTER’ WITH DMAA FOR 6 MONTHS 😱 I THOUGHT IT WAS JUST ‘GINSENG’ 😭 I’M GOING TO THE ER TOMORROW. I’M SO STUPID. I’M SORRY EVERYONE. I’M SORRY MY LIVER. I’M SORRY MY DOCTOR. 😭😭😭
Javier Rain
December 4, 2025Look, I get it. We want quick fixes. We’re tired. We’re stressed. We don’t have time to wait for meds to kick in.
But here’s the truth: if you’re taking something that says ‘boosts testosterone’ or ‘burns fat in 3 days,’ it’s not herbal. It’s a drug. And it’s illegal.
I used to sell these online. Not anymore. I saw a 24-year-old guy have a stroke after one bottle. That’s not a ‘side effect.’ That’s a crime.
Don’t be the next statistic. Bring the bottle. Ask the question. Be the one who speaks up.
Laurie Sala
December 6, 2025So… I’ve been taking kava for anxiety since 2020. My liver enzymes are elevated. My doctor said ‘maybe stop.’ But I don’t want to stop. I feel better. Isn’t that what matters?
…I’m just asking.
…I’m not mad. I’m just… confused.
…Do I have to choose between peace and my liver?
…I don’t want to be the problem.
Matthew Mahar
December 7, 2025wait so green tea extract is bad? but i thought green tea was good?? i just bought a big bottle of it from amazon for weight loss… oh no… i think i might be dead… 😬
Write a comment